← Sources & Criticism

60 points of conflict

Where the Sources Disagree

Each point where the documents contradict one another, the reading the chronicle carries, and the ones it set aside.

60 points of conflict recorded

  • Captain William Alfred Truman Maddox

    birth year · the chronicle uses 1814

  • Notley Maddox I

    will date · the chronicle uses 24 February 1716

  • Captain William Alfred Truman Maddox

    parentage · the chronicle uses unknown parents; no connected-tree lineage

  • Samuel Maddox Jr., later Green Springs owner

    birth year · the chronicle uses unresolved; person not mapped

  • George Francis Maddox

    death date · the chronicle uses unresolved; person not mapped

  • Lucy Virginia Lancaster Maddox

    birth date · the chronicle uses 25 November 1868

  • Julia Maddox, child named in the Green Springs compilation

    birth date · the chronicle uses unresolved; person not mapped

  • George William (Captain Willie) Maddox

    will and probate dates · the chronicle uses 18 March 1944 as the selected compilation's reading; probate unresolved

  • 1852 Green Springs conveyance

    interest conveyed · the chronicle uses documented three-fourths interest; remaining fourth unresolved

  • Mrs. Harry H. Wilhoit

    relationship to Captain Maddox · the chronicle uses granddaughter

  • John Maddox (generation 3)

    marriage year · the chronicle uses 1727

  • John Maddox (generation 3)

    death date · the chronicle uses 25 May 1785

  • Matthew Maddox, Jr. (generation 5)

    first marriage date (to Mary Ann Romine) · the chronicle uses 31 August 1801

  • Rozzel Maddox (generation 5)

    marriage place (to Mary Posey) · the chronicle uses Harrison County, Virginia (WV)

  • Dorcus Maddox (generation 5)

    death date · the chronicle uses c1869

  • Dorcus Maddox (generation 5)

    identity of second husband · the chronicle uses William White, Sr.

  • Charles E. Neale (husband of Dorcus Maddox)

    death date · the chronicle uses 1809

  • Alfred Alpheous Maddox (generation 5)

    marriage place (to Hannah Cassandra Barnes) · the chronicle uses Wood County, Virginia (WV)

  • Edward Tracewell (husband of Jane Teressa Neale)

    death date · the chronicle uses 14 March 1876

  • William Oscar Maddox and Anna Maria Elizabeth Cheuvront (generation 6)

    marriage date vs. first children's births · the chronicle uses all values retained verbatim

  • Rebecca Rose Maddox (generation 7)

    death date · the chronicle uses 17 October 1866

  • Mary Louisa Maddox (generation 7)

    marriage year (to James Harvey Currey) · the chronicle uses 13 December 1861

  • George C. Maddox (generation 7)

    marriage year (to Mahala Lockhart) · the chronicle uses 25 December 1856

  • Hannah Jane “Sis” Conger (wife of John Amos Maddox)

    death year · the chronicle uses 5 May 1905

  • John Amos Maddox (generation 8)

    second marriage year (to Bertha A. Smith) · the chronicle uses 18 June 1907-(1908)

  • George William Maddox (generation 9)

    death date · the chronicle uses 5 May 1976

  • James Ray Maddox (generation 10) and Esther Ann “Betty” Wise

    marriage date · the chronicle uses 18 June 1955

  • David Graham

    birth date · the chronicle uses 22 November 1955

  • Samuel (Madoc) Maddox (generation 1)

    arrival ship · the chronicle uses Good Intent is reported by the later charts; the earlier manuscript's uncertainty is retained.

  • Samuel (Madoc) Maddox (generation 1)

    first county-ledger year · the chronicle uses 1667 in the person note; both years retained here.

  • Ann (Anne) Notley

    death and remarriage chronology · the chronicle uses death unknown

  • Matthew Maddox, Jr. (generation 5)

    identity as a Baptist minister · the chronicle uses possible, but not established

  • John Amos Maddox (generation 8)

    acreage received for Matilda Cheuvront's care · the chronicle uses the tract is described without a resolved acreage

  • Geraldine Coen

    birth date · the chronicle uses 15 March 1925, corroborated by the two Eaton compilations and Geraldine's obituary; the May reading remains recorded here.

  • Nancy Alcinda McAtee

    death date · the chronicle uses 14 May 1884

  • Rufus Putnam Ingraham

    death date · the chronicle uses 28 April 1897

  • Lucy Noland

    birth date · the chronicle uses 16 August 1895 or 1896

  • James Ray Maddox

    military discharge date · the chronicle uses 2 June 1955

  • Rufus Putnam Ingraham and brothers

    Civil War militia service · the chronicle uses unverified research lead

  • Rachel Bonnifield

    birth year · the chronicle uses 1753

  • Ada B. Maddox

    birth date · the chronicle uses 27 November 1902

  • Harry Odell Maddox

    war associated with Army service · the chronicle uses World War I

  • Cornelius Maddox, early Maryland immigrant

    arrival year in Charles County, Maryland · the chronicle uses unresolved; no connected-tree identity

  • Amy Maddox and Robert Luther Fleming

    marriage county · the chronicle uses unresolved; marriage date retained without a place

  • Robert Luther Fleming

    death date · the chronicle uses 28 June 1894

  • Thomas Maddox, son of Martin G. Maddox and Julia Ann Romine

    birth date · the chronicle uses 11 April 1845

  • Roy Offa Enoch

    birthplace · the chronicle uses Jackson County, West Virginia

  • Roy Offa Enoch

    mother · the chronicle uses Minnie Swain

  • Stephen Robbins

    death date · the chronicle uses 10 February 1899

  • Anna Maria Elizabeth Cheuvront

    birth date · the chronicle uses 12 September 1804

  • Matilda (Bolin) Cheuvront

    birth date · the chronicle uses 2 June 1813

  • Samuel (Madoc) Maddox

    death year within Works family group sheet · the chronicle uses 1684

  • Samuel (Madoc) Maddox

    1678 tobacco amount characterization · the chronicle uses was due 700 pounds of tobacco as a public charge

  • Samuel (Madoc) Maddox

    will probate year · the chronicle uses 9 March 1684/5

  • Notley Maddox I

    Thomas Notley will date and tobacco bequest · the chronicle uses Thomas Notley's direct will text reports 2 April 1678 and 10,000 pounds of tobacco.

  • Mathew R. Maddox

    birth year · the chronicle uses 1818

  • John Amos Maddox and Bertha A. Smith

    marriage date · the chronicle uses 18 June 1907

  • Flora May Maddox and Charles Henry Kidd/McCauley

    marriage date · the chronicle uses 23 December 1907

  • George William Maddox and Laura Estella Robbins

    marriage date · the chronicle uses 31 July 1920

  • Katherine “Katie” Maddox

    birth year or marriage age · the chronicle uses 1866